<!-- copy: internal — QA verdict for c001-remake, machine-written, not ad copy -->

# QA — c001-remake (stage: final)

8 fatal, 1 major, 0 minor, 0 cosmetic (cosmetic = a viewer cannot see it at full speed)

| At | Kind | Severity | Notice | What |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Competitor Spotminders Tracking Card branded packaging is shown front and centre on screen, this is not the approved reference product. |
| 8.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | A solid red tracking card is shown, this does not match the black reference product, held clearly central frame next to a phone. |
| 17.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | The incorrect red tracking card is shown being placed into a wallet, wrong product displayed front and centre. |
| 20.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Incorrect red tracking card is placed on a wireless charging pad, wrong product fully visible central on screen. |
| 22.0s | identity | fatal | 3 | An unapproved unknown woman appears on screen holding wrong product packaging. This is not the specified reference actor for this ad. |
| 23.0s | identity | fatal | 3 | An unapproved unknown man appears on screen holding tracking cards. This is not the specified reference actor for this ad. |
| 24.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Multiple incorrect tracking cards (including red and wrong black variants) are laid out on the desk, wrong products are the focus of this shot. |
| 31.0s | identity | fatal | 3 | An unapproved unknown woman appears on screen holding the tracking card. This is not the specified reference actor for this ad. |
| 4.0s | hands | major | 2 | Extra distorted malformed fingers are visible on the hands placed over the wooden table, clearly visible at normal playback speed. |

## What the video says

I'm the last person in my bridge club who'd buy a gadget, and I did.  Setup runs through Apple Find My, already on every iPhone.  My granddaughter held the card near mine, tapped a couple of buttons,  and the map showed my handbag sitting in the kitchen.  That was the last time I thought about it.  At 1.8 millimeters thin, the card disappears inside my wallet,  and the battery has held up for eight months with no reminder.  Over 500,000 of us carry one of us.  The Buy 2, Get 1 free deal is running right now.  sister who keeps asking about yours.  The 100-day return window is still there if the setup trips you up.

## The reviewer, in full

```
[
{"t": 2.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Competitor Spotminders Tracking Card branded packaging is shown front and centre on screen, this is not the approved reference product."},
{"t": 4.0, "kind": "hands", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "Extra distorted malformed fingers are visible on the hands placed over the wooden table, clearly visible at normal playback speed."},
{"t": 8.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "A solid red tracking card is shown, this does not match the black reference product, held clearly central frame next to a phone."},
{"t": 17.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "The incorrect red tracking card is shown being placed into a wallet, wrong product displayed front and centre."},
{"t": 20.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Incorrect red tracking card is placed on a wireless charging pad, wrong product fully visible central on screen."},
{"t": 22.0, "kind": "identity", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "at_a_cut": true, "what": "An unapproved unknown woman appears on screen holding wrong product packaging. This is not the specified reference actor for this ad."},
{"t": 23.0, "kind": "identity", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "at_a_cut": true, "what": "An unapproved unknown man appears on screen holding tracking cards. This is not the specified reference actor for this ad."},
{"t": 24.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Multiple incorrect tracking cards (including red and wrong black variants) are laid out on the desk, wrong products are the focus of this shot."},
{"t": 31.0, "kind": "identity", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "at_a_cut": true, "what": "An unapproved unknown woman appears on screen holding the tracking card. This is not the specified reference actor for this ad."}
]
```