The QA verdict: 18 fatal defects, so neither cut is shippable
Run with tools/video_qa.py --stage final. The readable verdicts
ship with this page at c001 and c002. My own
eyeball check caught the pink card in 5 of 18 sampled frames and called it "several shots"; QA found it in 14 and
graded every one of them fatal, which is the honest number.
- Wrong product, 14 fatal. The donor films both a black card and a pink one, so wherever their card is
genuinely pink the model keeps that colour straight through the swap. Our card is matte black. On c002 at 9 seconds
the phone screen itself reads "Spotminders Tracking Card", so the model rebuilt the competitor's name inside the
handset even though it was removed from the card in the input. The fix is to recolour the card inside the input clips
and mask the phone screen, rather than ask the model again.
- Unapproved faces, 3 fatal. The secondary actors who hold the product are strangers rather than our cast,
because only the presenter has a reference sheet.
- Malformed hands, 1 fatal and 1 major, with fused and extra fingers in shots where the hands are the action.
- Two chunks still say "the car" where the line reads "the card." I added a note to the prompt telling the
model how to pronounce the word, and the model read that note aloud: one chunk ends with it speaking the word "Card"
as though it were a line. That note is coming out.